The difference between the two main heat dissipation methods, air cooling and liquid cooling, in lithium battery energy storage systems

 Energy storage systems, are devices capable of storing excess thermal energy, kinetic energy, electrical energy, potential energy, chemical energy, etc., in order to change the output capacity, output location, output time, etc., of energy, thereby rationalizing energy utilization and increasing energy efficiency. It’s like an oversized “power bank” that can release stored energy when needed.

Lithium-ion battery energy storage systems are a type of electrochemical energy storage, storing and releasing energy through chemical reactions. Currently, air cooling and liquid cooling are two commonly used cooling methods in lithium-ion battery energy storage systems.

1. Different application scenarios

The aircooling system has lower noise and minimal environmental impact. However, it may occupy a certain amount of internal structural space due to the installation of fans and radiators. It is suitable for various scales and types of energy storage systems, particularly demonstrating better applicability in outdoor environments. It is currently the most widely adopted cooling technology, applied in industrial refrigeration, communication base stations, data centers, temperature control scenarios, etc. Its technological maturity and reliability are relatively high. Especially in medium to low power scenarios, air cooling remains mainstream. It is suitable for low-power scenarios with low heat dissipation requirements, such as residential energy storage systems and small backup power supplies.

blog 0516 (1)

Air-cooled system battery cabinet

The liquid cooling system tends to produce higher noise levels, which can have some environmental impact. However, due to its smaller radiator size, it effectively saves internal structural space within the system. Additionally, liquid cooling can mitigate its environmental impact by optimizing radiator design and layout to reduce noise.

It is also suitable for various scales and types of energy storage systems, especially large-scale, high-energy density storage projects. Liquid cooling systems are particularly advantageous in scenarios with high battery pack energy density, fast charging and discharging rates, and significant environmental temperature fluctuations. They are suitable for high-power, high-density, or high-temperature environments, such as large-scale energy storage stations and electric vehicles.

2. Different heat dissipation principles and design complexities

Air cooling dissipates heat by airflow, reducing the surface temperature of the equipment. Its advantages include simple structure and low cost. However, its cooling effectiveness is greatly influenced by factors such as ambient temperature and airflow, making it unsuitable for high-power, high-density devices. Therefore, the design of air-cooled energy storage systems is relatively simple, mainly involving the installation of cooling fans and the design of airflow paths. The core of air cooling lies in the air conditioning and ductwork, where the air conditioning system cools while the ductwork exchanges heat.

blog 0516 (2)

Liquid cooling dissipates heat by using a liquid medium (such as water and a water-glycol solution) for thermal exchange, resulting in high cooling efficiency and more uniform temperature control across various components. Its advantages include superior cooling performance and high stability. However, it comes with higher costs and requires maintenance of the liquid circulation system. Therefore, liquid cooling designs are typically more complex, involving considerations such as layout of the liquid circulation system, pump selection, and maintenance of coolant circulation.

blog 0516 (3)
3.Differences in costs and corresponding exposure to risk

Air cooling systems have lower initial investment costs and are easier to maintain. However, due to limited cooling effectiveness, it may be necessary to increase the number of radiators or increase fan speeds to improve cooling efficiency. Attention must be paid to fan safety issues to prevent damage or overheating, thus increasing energy consumption and maintenance costs.

Liquid cooling systems require the use of high-quality materials and strict sealing designs to ensure the normal and stable operation of the liquid circulation system, resulting in higher initial investment costs.

blog 0516 (4)

All in all, liquid cooling systems excel in heat dissipation capability and temperature control but come with higher costs and system complexity. Air cooling systems, on the other hands, offer advantages in terms of cost and maintenance but have relatively weaker performance in heat dissipation efficiency and temperature uniformity. The choice between the two systems depends on specific application requirements and cost budgets.

Scroll to Top
Request A Quote Form